Month: May 2025

It’s late on a Friday night, and our team of investigators have tracked down a lead while investigating the theft of the Shadow Diamond. We’re instructed to send a core group of aspiring detectives to the gala to try and track down the thief. Once our group assembles at the gala event, a helpful bartender tunes our radio to the proper channel, and set us off on a narrative scavenger hunt that weaved across over a dozen buildings on the MIT campus, tracking down the locations of eleven blue paw prints. The twist: since this was a noir detective adventure, our audio helper only saw things in black and white, so many of the colorful signposts along the way were described in shades of gray – fifty, to be exact.

Eventually, our team realized that the film noir world of MITropolis we traced layered perfectly over a map of the MIT campus itself, and that cross-referencing the clues we discovered along the way paired with the locations of those Blue Clues spelled out the identity of the thief.

Armed with a name, our full team went up to the gala to confront the thief…only to discover that the culprit was murdered, and the diamond near the body was a fake, covered in scuff marks. Luckily, we were recognized for our efforts and upgraded to trainee detective status.

The MIT Mystery Hunt Means Something Different Every Year
At this point, the MIT Mystery Hunt might be the most covered immersive experience on ARGNet, with articles discussing the hunts in 2011, 2012, 2016, 2018, 2021, 2022, and 2023. And while the site skipped coverage of the annual event in 2024, that was because I was part of the team running that year’s hunt.

Some things have been constant about the MIT Mystery Hunt over that time. Hundreds of extremely smart puzzlers gather at MIT (either in person or virtually) over MLK Day weekend to push the boundaries of what a puzzle can be – both as puzzle constructors, and as solvers. There’s a narrative tying that experience together, structured around “feeder” puzzles, and meta-puzzles that use the answers of those feeder puzzles as inputs into a broader puzzle challenge. Teams have a long weekend in January to make it through the puzzles. And the reward for finishing the hunt first is a coin-like object, paired with the responsibility for running the next year’s Mystery Hunt.

Beyond that, the Mystery Hunt becomes an aspirational exercise in what the event can be, presented by teams that are excited about the event for very different reasons. And one of the most compelling questions asked by Death & Mayhem with their 2025 Mystery Hunt The Case of the Shadow Diamond was what it means to be a puzzle hunt community, in the first place.